Since 1982, Newman's Own salad dressings, juices, sauces, cookies, and pet food have been staples for baby boomers and Gen Xers who grew up watching Paul Newman on screen. The problem is generational. Newman died in 2008, and millennials do not know his filmography.
That is the assignment for new Chief Marketing Officer Mark Anthony Edmonson.
Two pillars:
Edmonson believes those messages resonate with millennials, who he describes as largely purpose-driven consumers, citing a recent CapitalOne Shopping report on millennial shopping statistics:
"Millennials care about their communities, they care about their planet, and they want to build a stronger future for the future generations," Edmonson said. "That's where Newman's Own fits so well into their lives."
Edmonson considers Newman's Own a challenger brand in crowded CPG categories where rivals hold significantly larger marketing budgets. The tools available are renewed social efforts, retail marketing, and fresh packaging.
The structural distinction matters here. Unlike larger companies that donate a small share of budget to a cause periodically, Newman's Own is owned by the brand's namesake foundation and has built purpose into the business for decades. Cumulative giving exceeds $600 million. Last year that money supported nutrition education and school food, taught indigenous children to grow, gather, and cook Native foods, and funded camps inclusive of kids facing medical challenges.
The most instructive change is on the package. Pizza boxes now carry protein callouts, and two old taglines were retired:
The reason is trust, not copywriting. For a demographic that, per Edmonson, often distrusts big CPG companies, the old line raised questions rather than answering them: do all the profits really go to charity, and how does the money actually help? The new line names the beneficiary.
New packaging has rolled out for pizzas, dressings, and beverages, with the rest of the portfolio scheduled for Q4 or Q1 of next year.
Over recent months the brand has pushed its mission through retail media activations at Walmart, Target, Chewy, Amazon, and Kroger, including sponsored search ads and displays.
In April, the company released smaller, more affordable salad dressing bottles with new flavors at Walmart, boosted through the retailer's displays and site search. On social, a content creator discussed the collaboration, the product, and the charitable contributions while making a salad.
The reported results:
That last figure is the interesting one. Most of the volume came from buyers new to the brand rather than repeat purchasers.
In May the brand revised its social strategy, moving away from larger creators whose scripted videos sounded "descriptive." The goal became content that reads as authentic — creators who share the company's values, believe its story, and can amplify it with their own audiences.
Last month the channels joined the "That's my why" trend, where people share their underlying motivations. "Paul Newman didn't just start a food brand…" the TikTok post read over a reel of the actor's photos. "He started a brand built to give back. 100% of our profits help kids in need. And that's our why."
It drew nearly 20,000 likes, 377 comments, 331 shares, and roughly 900 new followers.
Purpose survives scrutiny only when it is structural. A foundation owning the company is not something a campaign can manufacture, which is precisely why it holds up against millennial skepticism.
The tagline swap was a trust fix, not a copy fix. "We give it all away" is beautiful and unverifiable. "100% of profits help kids in need" names a recipient. For a suspicious audience, specificity beats poetry.
Nostalgia is a bridge, not a destination. Many millennials recognize the brand because their parents kept it in the house, and that recognition is the entry point for trust. A stronger millennial relationship then reaches their children — a transfer pattern consistent with research showing mothers outrank creators in Gen Alpha brand choice.
Also worth watching: the widening range of ways brands convert values into advertising assets, as when Liquid Death turned data center backlash into a 90-second campaign.
Edmonson's stated one-year objective is to become "more culturally relevant with this millennial consumer," where relevancy means "helping them understand our unique value in their lives." The work is restating a 40-year-old asset in a new generation's language.
The brand's namesake foundation owns the company, and 100% of profits go annually to charities helping children facing adversity. Cumulative giving exceeds $600 million.
The previous lines prompted skepticism about whether profits truly went to charity and how the money helped. The new lines name the beneficiary, making the claim easier to verify.
For the Walmart activation, the company reported $3.50 in revenue per $1 of ad spend, a 49% conversion rate, 43% digital penetration, and a 70% new-to-brand rate.
The brand moved away from larger creators using scripted, descriptive messaging toward creators who genuinely share its values and can carry the story to their own audiences.
To apply what you just read to your own site, start with a free audit of where things are now.
A strategist replies within 24 hours on business days.
In CreatorIQ's survey of 5,095 creators, suitability topped the creator selection criteria and follower count came dead last. Yet follower count still predicts pay better than anything else.
Brand equity comes from accumulation, not novelty. How a Korean travel platform kept the same jingle for six years without stagnating.
Chipotle turned a 16-year-old YouTube star's order into a limited Kid's Meal, extending a custom-order tactic that worked on Gen Z to a younger cohort.